Insurance fraud is one piece of the international criminal jigsaw

Insurance Fraud Director, BAE Systems Applied Intelligence Read time: 3 mins
Insurance companies have long suspected that organised insurance fraud is linked to wider criminal activity. Establishing that connection as fact has limited value in combating organised fraud itself, but it could play an important role in reducing opportunistic fraud
Insurance fraud is one piece of the international criminal jigsawOpportunists are not driven by the same motivations as criminals. The former are, more often than not, acting either in desperation or in reaction to a seemingly attractive chance to carry out what they might see as a victimless crime.
 
Those who inflate an insurance claim for extra cash do not see themselves as having much in common with people traffickers or murderers. But this link is exactly what the industry needs to demonstrate to build necessary stigma around insurance fraud.
 
There is little data to unequivocally show that organised fraud in the insurance industry is linked to broader criminal networks, but the anecdotal evidence is plentiful.
 
In 2017 Mohammed Sangak was jailed by a British court for 10 years. He had run a crash-for-cash scam that netted hundreds of thousands of pounds. However, the boundaries of Sangak’s criminal enterprise stretched far beyond insurance fraud. He was also convicted of plotting to smuggle illegal immigrants into the UK.
 
In America in 2016, Philadelphia auto-body shop owner Ronald Galati was sentenced to up 29 years in prison for defrauding insurance companies (with 40 other co-conspirators) of nearly $2 million through motor fraud.
 
Again, insurance fraud was not the sole criminal enterprise. When convicted, Galati was already in jail for several murder-for-hire plots.
 

Organised criminals are targeting insurance companies

Although these are just two examples, they show that organised criminals are targeting insurance companies as just one element of their wide-ranging illicit activities. Insurance fraud is not their sole purpose.
 
When we look at criminal activity from a global perspective, we start to see how local organised crime fits into a much broader landscape. The global trade system is incredibly complex, with trillions of dollars going through ports every year. This has happened less by design than by evolution – and the global crime system has evolved in line with it.
 
A massive chunk of global trade is criminal, with one trillion dollars of proceeds passing through the system every year. Criminal gangs trade online globally in much the same way that small companies do.
 
The connections between the small and the big criminal players are hugely intricate, with criminals of all types trading with each other, just as businesses do. While local criminals are unlikely to be troubled by being bracketed together with global criminal gangs (a connection they may, indeed, savour), opportunistic fraudsters will likely baulk at such an association.
 
If insurers continue to work in establishing and exposing the links between insurance fraud and far more serious crimes, they can build much-needed stigma around insurance fraud, reducing its incidence as well as helping to build a safer society.
 

Find out more about the author:

 

Get the report now:

Know Your Enemy

Know Your Enemy: How Insurers Can Understand the Evolving Threat of Financial Crime

Knowing your enemy is key in the fight against financial crime. Get an up-to-date picture of the criminal line-up.
Find out more
 
top
Chris Andrew CII Insurance Fraud Director, BAE Systems Applied Intelligence 12 February 2020